Celtic FC vs. Livingston FC: Tactical Analysis of Recent Encounters

C

The 2023-2024 season has seen several engaging encounters between Celtic FC and Livingston FC, both in the Scottish Premiership and Scottish Cup. These fixtures have not only highlighted contrasting tactical approaches but also showcased moments of individual brilliance and resilience. 

Celtic, traditionally the stronger side, proved their dominance in both encounters, but Livingston’s tactical discipline and commitment presented challenges that kept the games competitive. Let’s analyze the tactics and key moments from two notable matches between these two teams.

March 10, 2024: Scottish Cup Quarter-Final at Celtic Park

In a thrilling Scottish Cup quarter-final, Celtic secured a 4-2 victory over Livingston at Celtic Park. The match was a true spectacle, with Celtic establishing an early lead, only for Livingston to fight back and level the score before Celtic’s late surge sealed the win.

Celtic FC’s 4-3-3 Formation:

Goalkeeper: Joe Hart (Captain)

Defenders: Alistair Johnston, Stephen Welsh, Liam Scales, Greg Taylor

Midfielders: Matt O’Riley, Tomoki Iwata, Paulo Bernardo

Forwards: Luis Palma, Kyogo Furuhashi, Daizen Maeda

Celtic’s 4-3-3 setup was designed for fluid attacking play and defensive stability. The midfield trio of Callum McGregor, Matt O’Riley, and Paulo Bernardo was pivotal in controlling the game. 

Their combination of passing, creativity, and defensive support allowed Celtic to dominate possession and link defense to attack. Up front, the dynamic duo of Daizen Maeda and Kyogo Furuhashi provided pace and clinical finishing, both of which were evident in this match.

Livingston FC’s 3-6-1 Formation:

Goalkeeper: Shamal George

Defenders: Nicky Devlin (Captain), Ayo Obileye, Jack Fitzwater

Midfielders: Scott Pittman, Jason Holt, Sean Kelly, Andrew Shinnie, Steven Bradley, Jaze Kabia

Forward: Terence Yengi

Livingston employed a 3-6-1 formation, aiming to crowd the midfield and provide support to the lone striker, Terence Yengi. Their approach sought to control the center of the pitch and frustrate Celtic by denying space for their attacking players. 

This defensive solidity was disrupted by Celtic’s quick transitions and wide play, which stretched Livingston’s defensive structure. Despite Livingston’s efforts to regain control, Celtic’s quality and tactical flexibility proved decisive in the final stages of the match.

Match Highlights and Key Moments:

The match kicked off with Celtic quickly asserting their dominance. Daizen Maeda opened the scoring in the 7th minute, followed by a second goal from Maeda in the 22nd minute. However, Livingston responded with resilience. 

David Mackay scored in the 12th minute, narrowing the deficit, and Terence Yengi found the back of the net in the 54th minute, leveling the score at 2-2. Despite Livingston’s fightback, Maeda completed his hat-trick in the 86th minute, and Kyogo Furuhashi sealed the win with a goal in the dying seconds of injury time.

Celtic’s quick transitions and wide play were key in breaking down Livingston’s defensive setup. Maeda’s pace and finishing proved too much for Livingston’s defense, while Furuhashi’s movement ensured that Celtic capitalized on the opportunities they created. Livingston, on the other hand, lacked the clinical edge to capitalize on their chances, despite some solid performances, particularly from Terence Yengi and Jason Holt.

March 31, 2024: Scottish Premiership at Tony Macaroni Arena

In this Scottish Premiership fixture at Tony Macaroni Arena, Celtic emerged victorious once again, with a commanding 3-0 win. The match saw a first-half own goal by Livingston’s Jaze Kabia, followed by goals from Paulo Bernardo and Matt O’Riley to seal the victory for Celtic.

Livingston FC’s 4-3-3 Formation:

Goalkeeper: Shamal George

Defenders: Nicky Devlin (Captain), Ayo Obileye, Jack Fitzwater, Jaze Kabia

Midfielders: Scott Pittman, Jason Holt, Sean Kelly

Forwards: Steven Bradley, Terence Yengi, Andrew Shinnie

In this encounter, Livingston adopted a 4-3-3 formation, focusing on a compact midfield and utilizing their wide players in attack. The defensive line was anchored by Ayo Obileye and Jack Fitzwater, with Nicky Devlin providing leadership and defensive organization.

 Livingston’s main threat came from their wide players, including Steven Bradley and Andrew Shinnie, who sought to create opportunities for Terence Yengi, the lone striker.

Celtic FC’s 4-3-3 Formation:

Goalkeeper: Joe Hart (Captain)

Defensive Line: Alistair Johnston, Cameron Carter-Vickers, Liam Scales, Greg Taylor

Midfielders: Callum McGregor (Captain), Matt O’Riley, Paulo Bernardo

Forwards: Luis Palma, Kyogo Furuhashi, Daizen Maeda

Once again, Celtic employed their 4-3-3 formation, with the midfield trio of McGregor, O’Riley, and Bernardo controlling the tempo of the game. Their ability to dominate possession and switch play quickly stretched Livingston’s defensive lines. In attack, Furuhashi’s intelligent movement and Maeda’s pace were key in creating space and forcing Livingston into mistakes.

Match Highlights and Key Moments:

The game was defined by an early own goal from Livingston’s Jaze Kabia in the 49th minute. Kabia’s unfortunate error came from a cross into the box, which he inadvertently turned into his own net. 

Celtic then capitalized on their advantage, with Paulo Bernardo scoring in the 72nd minute after a well-worked team move. Matt O’Riley sealed the victory with a third goal in the 82nd minute, showing his composure in front of goal.

Livingston struggled to break down Celtic’s defensive structure, as the visitors maintained their compact shape and stifled Livingston’s attacking play. Despite some individual efforts from Jason Holt and Terence Yengi, Livingston was unable to create significant chances. Celtic’s ability to control possession, coupled with their clinical finishing, ensured that they walked away with a comfortable victory.

Player Performances

Celtic FC:

Joe Hart (Goalkeeper): A reliable presence in goal, Hart made crucial saves when needed and led his team from the back.

Matt O’Riley (Midfielder): O’Riley was influential in both fixtures, providing creativity in midfield and scoring vital goals.

Daizen Maeda (Forward): Maeda’s pace and finishing ability were key to Celtic’s success, especially in the Scottish Cup quarter-final, where he netted a hat-trick.

Livingston FC:

Ayo Obileye (Defender): A solid performer in defense, Obileye showed composure and aerial strength, trying to keep Celtic’s attackers at bay.

Jason Holt (Midfielder): Holt was central to Livingston’s midfield, breaking up Celtic’s attacks and trying to dictate play when on the ball.

Terence Yengi (Forward): Yengi was a constant threat in attack, scoring in the Scottish Cup and showing his hold-up play in both matches.

Final Thought

The encounters between Celtic and Livingston during the 2023-2024 season highlighted the tactical diversity and competitive spirit of Scottish football. Celtic’s superior quality, coupled with their tactical flexibility, ensured their success in both fixtures. 

Despite Livingston’s organizational resilience, their lack of clinical finishing and inability to fully stifle Celtic’s attacking threat ultimately cost them. These matches underscored the importance of tactical discipline, individual moments of brilliance, and the need to capitalize on key opportunities in Scottish football.

FAQs

Q: How did the lineups differ in the March 31, 2024, match between Livingston and Celtic?

A: In the Scottish Premiership fixture on March 31, 2024, Livingston’s lineup was:

Goalkeeper: Shamal George

Defenders: Ayo Obileye, Nicky Devlin, Jack Fitzwater

Midfielders: Jason Holt, Sean Kelly, Andrew Shinnie, Stephane Omeonga, James Penrice, Nicky Cadden

Forward: Bruce Anderson

Celtic’s lineup featured:

Goalkeeper: Joe Hart (Captain)

Defenders: Alistair Johnston, Stephen Welsh, Liam Scales, Greg Taylor

Midfielders: Matt O’Riley, Tomoki Iwata, Paulo Bernardo

Forwards: Luis Palma, Kyogo Furuhashi, Daizen Maeda

This match ended in a 3-0 victory for Celtic.

Q: Where can I find detailed lineups for past matches between Celtic and Livingston?

A: Detailed lineups for these matches are available on sports news websites such as Sky Sports and BeSoccer.

Q: How can I watch highlights of the Celtic vs. Livingston matches?

A: Match highlights are typically available on the official YouTube channels of the respective clubs and on sports news platforms like ESPN.

Q: Are there any upcoming fixtures between Celtic and Livingston?

A: As of December 18, 2024, there are no scheduled matches between Celtic and Livingston. For the most current fixture information, it’s advisable to check the official websites of both clubs or reputable sports news outlets.
To read more, click here.

About the author

Runa Khan

Add Comment